The Fingering Chart

For parents · Guide

Rent or Buy a Band Instrument? A Parent's Guide

How rental credit works at different stores, when buying makes sense, and why the cheapest instrument online often costs the most.

Why most beginners start with a rental

Music & Arts, which has about 500 rental locations, says most band and orchestra students begin on a rental [1]. The reasons are practical. A monthly payment is easier to manage than a large one up front, and a rental lets a child try the instrument before the family commits to it [1]. Returns and exchanges are free there, so a student who switches from saxophone to clarinet in October isn't stuck with the wrong instrument [1].

A store owner interviewed by the Illinois Times gave the same advice: if your student isn't sure which instrument to play, or you need more time, rent [4].

There's also a reason that has nothing to do with money. A retired high school band director in the same story said the quickest way to lose a beginner is to hand them an instrument that doesn't work [4]. Rental programs check their instruments before they go out. Sweetwater, for example, says it rents only educator-approved instruments and puts each one through a 40-point inspection [2].

Rental credit doesn't mean the same thing everywhere

Most stores say your rent "counts toward" buying. What that means varies a lot, and it decides whether renting first was a good deal.

StoreHow rent countsFine print
Sweetwater100% of rental principal payments apply to buying the instrument [2]Buy any time, with an extra early purchase discount; no minimum rental period [2]
Hickey's Music CenterRent is credited toward a new step-up or professional instrument of the same kind, not the rental itself [3]Only one rental term counts, the credit has to be used within 30 days of the rental ending, and unused credit is forfeited [3]
Music & ArtsPayment options let rental payments count toward a purchase [1]Ask for the exact terms on the instrument you rent

Hickey's calls its plan "rent-to-rent" rather than rent-to-own [3]. Neither approach is wrong, but they suit different families. A plan like Sweetwater's rewards a student who stays on the same instrument. A plan like Hickey's rewards a student who will move up to a better instrument after a year or two.

Worked example: how a rental credit adds up

Hickey's FAQ walks through its own math, and it shows why the details matter [3].

  1. Your student rents a flute, and over the rental you pay $400 in rent. The monthly damage plan, sales tax and fees don't count toward the credit [3].
  2. You decide to buy a new step-up flute with a list price (MSRP) of $1,000. The store's usual discount brings its price to $700 [3].
  3. The store subtracts your $400 credit from the $1,000 list price first, leaving $600, and then takes its 30% discount off that. You pay $420 instead of $700 [3].

Now change one detail. If the rental had ended more than 30 days earlier, the credit would be gone [3]. If the family had rented under two separate terms, only one of them would count [3]. Before you sign, get the store to show you the same kind of calculation for the instrument your child is renting.

Damage plans and insurance

Rental stores sell monthly protection plans, and it's worth knowing what they don't cover.

  • Sweetwater says most outside insurance policies don't cover rented instruments [2]. Its protection plan lets you exchange the instrument when it needs repair, and it usually ships a replacement the same day you ask [2].
  • Hickey's Peace of Mind plan covers damage and repair service, but not loss or theft. For those, the store points families to their homeowners or renters insurance [3].
  • Once you own an instrument, repairs come out of your pocket unless you buy a maintenance plan, which Music & Arts offers on purchases [1].

When buying makes sense

Renting can cost more than buying in the long run if a child sticks with music for years, and Music & Arts says buying may be the better value for students who are already committed [1].

Buying used is the other way to save. A Bloomington store co-owner quoted by the Illinois Times said good, playable name-brand instruments in working order usually sell for about half the price of new ones [4]. A purchase guide that a school band program shares with parents adds that a used name-brand instrument can cost about the same as a generic new one [5]. The used instrument checklist covers what to look at before you pay.

The cheap instrument trap

That school band guide spends most of its space on one warning: "stencil" brands, which copy another maker's design and are mass-produced, often sold very cheaply online [5]. The trouble with them:

  • Repair technicians often won't work on them or can't get parts, so a broken one usually has to be replaced [5].
  • Some are made of metal that is too soft or too brittle to repair [5].
  • Established makers that design and build their own instruments, such as Yamaha, Bach, Selmer Paris and Gemeinhardt, use standard parts a technician can fix [5].

The guide's rule is simple: don't buy an instrument that can't be repaired [5]. A trumpet teacher in the Illinois Times story warned about lookalike names on resale sites, such as "Selman" passing for Selmer, and said that if you haven't heard of a brand, ask someone before you buy [4]. A repair technician in the same story said cheap instruments that don't play properly can actually hold a student back, and that most kids quit when the instrument fights them [4].

Ending a rental

If your child quits or switches, find out exactly when the payments stop. Hickey's rentals aren't tied to the school calendar, so they keep running over the summer unless you return the instrument, and a rental only ends once the instrument is back at the store [3]. Sweetwater charges only for the time between the day the instrument arrives and the day it gets back to them. Keep the original box, ask for a return label and drop it off at FedEx [2]. Either way, a rental forgotten in a closet over the summer keeps costing money.

Questions to ask before you sign

  • Does the rent count toward this instrument, or only toward a different, new one [2][3]?
  • Is it all of the rent or only part of it, and does the damage plan count [2][3]?
  • Is there a discount for buying early [2][3]?
  • Is there a minimum rental period, and how do returns work [2]?
  • Does the protection plan cover loss and theft, or only damage [3]?
  • Is the rental instrument new or previously rented [3]?
  • Can we switch to a different instrument if my child changes their mind [1][3]?
  • Does the credit expire when the rental ends [3]?

Ask the band director too. The school band guide asks parents to contact a director before buying, whatever the budget [5].

Common mistakes

  • Buying the shiny bargain online. A new instrument that a repair shop won't fix isn't a bargain [5].
  • Assuming home insurance covers a rental. Most outside policies don't [2].
  • Assuming the damage plan covers theft. Some don't [3].
  • Assuming every rent-to-own plan works the same way. Compare the terms side by side [2][3].
  • Letting the credit expire at the end of a rental [3].
  • Buying before your child has tried the instrument. Renting first lets them find out [1].
  • Skipping the band director. Directors know which brands and models work for their program [5].

If you go the used route instead, have a repair technician look the instrument over before you pay. In the 2009 Illinois Times story, one technician charged $15 for an evaluation, then fixed dents, pads and key adjustments only if the instrument was worth the money [4]. Ask your local shop what it charges today.

Sources

  1. Renting vs. Purchasing an Instrument: Pros, Cons & Questions, Music & Arts
  2. Getting Started and Rental Basics, Sweetwater
  3. Rental FAQ, Hickey's Music Center
  4. Rent or buy, new or used? (DiAnne Crown), Illinois Times
  5. Instrument Purchase Guide (Bradley Mariska), Sims Band
For parentsHow to Check a Used Band Instrument Before You BuyA checklist for pads, cracks, dents, valves and slides, the brands repair shops can fix, and how to tell when a bargain isn't one.Read the guide →Getting startedThe Band Brass Family ComparedHow the six brass instruments in a school band differ in tubing, valves, mouthpiece and clef, and which trumpet fingerings carry over to mellophone and euphonium.Read the guide →SaxophoneSoprano, Alto, Tenor and Baritone Saxophones ComparedThe four saxophones in a school band share one set of fingerings, so what changes from one to the next is the size of the horn and what it asks of your embouchure and air.Read the guide →